New York City vs New York Red Bulls
Head-to-head record and recent meetings.
Last 12 meetings
| 19 Sep 26 | N0–1 | Major League Soccer · New York City home | details → |
| 18 Sep 26 | N0–1 | Major League Soccer · New York City home | details → |
| 17 May 26 | D1–1 | Major League Soccer · New York Red Bulls home | details → |
| 16 May 26 | D1–1 | Major League Soccer · New York Red Bulls home | details → |
| 28 Sep 25 | N3–2 | Major League Soccer · New York Red Bulls home | details → |
| 27 Sep 25 | N3–2 | Major League Soccer · New York Red Bulls home | details → |
| 17 May 25 | N2–0 | Major League Soccer · New York City home | details → |
| 23 Nov 24 | N0–2 | Major League Soccer · New York City home | details → |
| 29 Sep 24 | N5–1 | Major League Soccer · New York Red Bulls home | details → |
| 28 Sep 24 | N5–1 | Major League Soccer · New York Red Bulls home | details → |
| 19 May 24 | N2–1 | Major League Soccer · New York City home | details → |
| 18 May 24 | N2–1 | Major League Soccer · New York City home | details → |
Scores shown from New York City's perspective. From graded matches on record.